The Official Web Site of
Jonas Maxwell
Current Las Vegas Time:
Supporting the God-given freedom America's Founding Fathers fought and died for!
print this page email this page to a friend

Booting the Biggest Booties

Categories: Opinion

On February 13, 2010, film director Kevin Smith was told by Southwest Airlines he was too fat to fly unless he paid for two seats (CBS News).  Emery Orto was kicked off of a Southwest Airlines flight for being too fat (abcnews).  So was Chip [last name unknown], a Southwest Airlines frequent flier (his blog).  And a "Chicagoland man" (

Does there appear to be a pattern here?

Reasons for the boot range from pre-flight "weight and balance" issues to potential evacuation risks to discomfort of passengers who might be seated next to the alleged offenders.  Whatever the excuses given, Southwest claims it's a safety issue.

Many people support Southwest's policy.  And, although I think Southwest's decision is a poor one, if that's what Southwest passengers want, that's what they should get.  The problem, as I see it, is not Southwest's decision - they are, after all, an American company operating in what is supposed to be a free market in a Democratic society - it's how Southwest is making those decisions.  They allow passengers to buy tickets, then tell them at the last minute that they cannot continue on the flight.  In some cases, they allow the passengers to board the aircraft before kicking them off.

Southwest's goal is to fill up each flight by selling as many tickets as they can, then singling out the passengers who appear to be the heaviest.  This is in Southwest's best interest since it allows them to keep the highest number of passengers.  But wouldn't a first come-first served method be more fair?  In other words, if the total allowable weight of any particular flight is over the limits, shouldn't the last person to buy a ticket be bumped bumped?  LIFO, as computer programmers would say - last in, first out.  If that didn't bring the weight down sufficiently, the airline could go to the next to the last passengers to purchase tickets, and so on until the weight was acceptable.  Of course, this might mean that two or three or even more passengers be bumped, rather than the one overweight passenger.  Not gonna happen.


If Southwest is going to continue with this policy, here's how they should implement it:

  1. Require that each passenger report their weight when purchasing a ticket.  (Baggage weight can be estimated initially and verified at check in, as they currently do.)
  2. The maximum allowable weight for each aircraft type is already established by the aircraft manufacturers.
  3. When the combined total weight of all passengers meets or exceeds the total allowable weight, all ticket sales cease.  The flight will be considered "sold out" regardless of how many seats are empty or full.

The problem here is that some flights may have empty seats when there are passengers willing to fill them, even knowing the flight is overweight and a potential safety risk.  On the other hand, the passengers who made it onto the flight first would probably not be willing to accept the risk, since they might actually be the ones to suffer.  So with this system, Southwest would have empty seats, which means a decrease in revenue.  But safety first, right?  Or not.

Although that would be a fair procedure for all involved, it may not be the most profitable.  And, of course, Southwest, and any other commercial airline carrier, is not in the business to be fair; they are in the business to make a profit.  And by booting the biggest booties, apparently Southwest believes that's how they're going to remain competitive.  But are they shooting themselves in the foot with the repetitious negative publicity?

Southwest happens to be my favorite airline.  This despite the fact that their director of flight operations, Gregg Crum, believes the missile that flew past my 1998 Southwest flight was a "Boeing MD-80" (McDonnell-Douglas makes the MD-80, not Boeing).  In any case, I like what Southwest has done, that is, provide safe and efficient air transportion at a reasonable price.

On the other hand, I'm a man of principles, and I'm doing my best to treat others with respect and compassion, so when I find a just cause I like to support it.  But do I really want to battle my favorite airline?

It turns out the question is moot.  I can oppose Southwest's policy based on principle, but I don't have to boycott them.  You see, I'd rather not fly at all any more.  On any airline.  It's simply not worth the hassle.  As much as I love to travel, I also love to drive, and there's a lot to see and do in the U.S.  So I'll do my part to support those who are unfairly treated, but if I really, really need to fly again, I'll probably go on Southwest.

"If you can't say something nice, let's hear it!"   — Joan Rivers

You got something to say about Booting the Biggest Booties?

NOTE: A message sent through this form will not be sent privately to Jonas.  It will be posted on this page for the entire world to see.  Any responses will also be posted on this page, and you will not receive personal responses.  If you would like to send a private message to Jonas, send a message through the contact page.  He can ignore it much faster that way. (Just kidding!)


NEXT: Pass the word - it's possible to choke on food


kiva - loans that change lives
Kiva - loans that change lives
New Pages
ELP - An International Collaboration MUSIC ELP - An International Collaboration - I got out of music when I realized there are extraordinarily talented musicians in the world, and I wasn't one of them. Three of those musicians formed Emerson, Lake & Palmer in 1970. I didn't listen to them until the mid-70s. "Karn Evil 9" perform... more (Updated Nov 4, 2017)

Tina S Cover of Ludwig von Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata, 3rd Movement MUSIC Tina S Cover of Ludwig von Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata, 3rd Movement - If you don't know this piece, you'll think this is just another awesome, mind-blowing electric guitar solo. If you do know this piece, as Beethoven wrote it, you'll be blown away at the talent of this young girl (only 17 when this was published on Yo... more (Updated Aug 22, 2017)

Cover of the Week: Cowsills Hair MUSIC Cover of the Week: Cowsills Hair - Remember this song? I was a Cowsills fan as a boy, but I don't think I ever confessed it. Until now. There were two Cowsills songs that stand out: The Rain, The Park & Other Things and Hair, the Cowsills most successful hit. This 2007 live PBS telev... more (Updated Aug 18, 2017)

Wishing Well - Terence Trent D'Arby Cover MUSIC Wishing Well - Terence Trent D'Arby Cover - Jolan sings 'Wishing Well', a Terence Trent D'Arby cover song.... more (Updated Aug 11, 2017)

Chase Holfelder Cover of Elle King's 'Ex's and Oh's' MUSIC Chase Holfelder Cover of Elle King's 'Ex's and Oh's' - Chase Holfelder cover of Elle King's 'Ex's and Oh's'.... more (Updated Jun 30, 2017)


home     media     calendar     faqs     contact

© 2010-2013 Jonas Maxwell. All rights reserved.