The Official Web Site of
Jonas Maxwell
Current Las Vegas Time:
Supporting the God-given freedom America's Founding Fathers fought and died for!
 
Crime
print this page email this page to a friend

Not Dunn Yet - The Jury's Baffling Decisions

Categories: Crime

Defendant Michael Dunn
Defendant Michael Dunn
Michael Dunn was convicted today of attempted murder for shooting into a carful of teenagers after an argument about their loud music.

My heart goes out to Dunn and his supporters, to the family and friends of deceased Jordan Davis, and the three other occupants, Tommie Stornes, Leland Brunson, and Tevin Thompson.

But there seems to me to be a problem with the jury's decisions.

While jurors couldn't agree on the most serious charge of first-degree murder, the 12 jurors found Dunn guilty of three counts of attempted second-degree murder.

This makes no sense.

I'm not even going to get into whether Dunn was guilty or not guilty.  My interest is in the jury's baffling decisions and inconsistency.

Dunn fired ten rounds, nine of which hit the SUV with four teens inside.  One of the teens, 17-year-old Jordan Davis, was killed.

The verdict of guilty on three counts of attempted second-degree murder means that the jurors agreed that Dunn intentionally tried to kill three of those four teens (I can only assume those were the three teens in the car who survived).  More importantly, that decision means that the jurors did not believe Dunn acted in self-defense, for if he had, he could not have been found guilty of attempted murder.

Although the jurors agreed that Dunn was not acting in self-defense in the shooting of the three teens who survived, they could not reach that same conclusion in the shooting of Davis who died.

The jury also couldn't agree that Dunn intentionally tried to kill Davis.  If they did, they would have found Dunn guilty of at least second-degree murder since the shots that killed Davis were the same shots that were fired into the SUV occupied by the three others who survived, and they found Dunn guilty on three counts of attempted second-degree murder.

It seems to me that the charges among the four victims would be tied together.  If Dunn was acting in self-defense, that act would apply to all four of the teens.  The fact that one died and the other three didn't would be irrelevent.

If Dunn was found guilty of attempted second-degree murder against the three survivors, he must be found guilty of murder - either first-degree or second-degree - against the victim who actually died.

If the jury could not find Dunn guilty of murdering Davis, they could not then conclude that he was guilty of attempted murder of the other three occupants.

I think we're only getting started on this one.


"If you can't say something nice, let's hear it!"   — Joan Rivers

You got something to say about Not Dunn Yet - The Jury's Baffling Decisions?

NOTE: A message sent through this form will not be sent privately to Jonas.  It will be posted on this page for the entire world to see.  Any responses will also be posted on this page, and you will not receive personal responses.  If you would like to send a private message to Jonas, send a message through the contact page.  He can ignore it much faster that way. (Just kidding!)

name
comments

NEXT: I-TEAM: Crossing the Line into Area 51 Gets Caught on Camera

(2294)

kiva - loans that change lives
Kiva - loans that change lives
New Pages
ELP - An International Collaboration MUSIC ELP - An International Collaboration - I got out of music when I realized there are extraordinarily talented musicians in the world, and I wasn't one of them. Three of those musicians formed Emerson, Lake & Palmer in 1970. I didn't listen to them until the mid-70s. "Karn Evil 9" perform... more (Updated Nov 4, 2017)

Tina S Cover of Ludwig von Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata, 3rd Movement MUSIC Tina S Cover of Ludwig von Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata, 3rd Movement - If you don't know this piece, you'll think this is just another awesome, mind-blowing electric guitar solo. If you do know this piece, as Beethoven wrote it, you'll be blown away at the talent of this young girl (only 17 when this was published on Yo... more (Updated Aug 22, 2017)

Cover of the Week: Cowsills Hair MUSIC Cover of the Week: Cowsills Hair - Remember this song? I was a Cowsills fan as a boy, but I don't think I ever confessed it. Until now. There were two Cowsills songs that stand out: The Rain, The Park & Other Things and Hair, the Cowsills most successful hit. This 2007 live PBS telev... more (Updated Aug 18, 2017)

Wishing Well - Terence Trent D'Arby Cover MUSIC Wishing Well - Terence Trent D'Arby Cover - Jolan sings 'Wishing Well', a Terence Trent D'Arby cover song.... more (Updated Aug 11, 2017)

Chase Holfelder Cover of Elle King's 'Ex's and Oh's' MUSIC Chase Holfelder Cover of Elle King's 'Ex's and Oh's' - Chase Holfelder cover of Elle King's 'Ex's and Oh's'.... more (Updated Jun 30, 2017)

 

home     media     calendar     faqs     contact

© 2010-2013 Jonas Maxwell. All rights reserved.